- Americas Best Value Inn New Paltz8.4New Paltz
- Holiday Inn Poughkeepsie by IHG7.3Poughkeepsie
- Hampton Inn by Hilton New Paltz, NYNew Paltz9.2
- Colonial InnPine Hill7.9
- The Gables of Rhinebeck9.1Rhinebeck
- Margaretville Mountain Inn B&B9.0Margaretville
- Village MotelEllenville7.1
- Phoenicia Lodge8.6Phoenicia
- Hotel Dylan8.8Woodstock
- YO1 Longevity & Health Resorts, CatskillsMonticello6.9
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites - Saugerties - Hudson Valley by IHGSaugerties8.5
- Play All Day - Sleep By The Stream at Night - Swimming HolePalenville9.3
- Mirbeau Inn & Spa, RhinebeckRhinebeck9.4
- Catskill Seasons Inn7.8Shandaken
- The Kartrite Resort and Indoor WaterparkMonticello7.7
- Newly Renovated 3BR Hudson Valley HouseUlster Park9.6
- The Woodbine InnPalenville8.9
- Comfort Inn Saugerties4.5Saugerties
- Hampton Inn & Suites Poughkeepsie8.7Spackenkill
- Hampton Inn Kingston8.6Kingston
- Residence Inn Poughkeepsie8.6Poughkeepsie
- Knights Inn Liberty2.7Liberty
- Starlite Motel & SuitesBig Indian8.2
- Holiday Inn Express Poughkeepsie by IHG8.4Poughkeepsie
- Margaretville Motel6.6Margaretville
- Pine Hill Arms Hotel7.3Pine Hill
- DoubleTree by Hilton Poughkeepsie8.4Poughkeepsie
- Renwick Clifton House B&BSaugerties9.7
- Elegantly English CatskillsLiberty9.1
- Resorts World Catskills8.1Monticello
- Courtyard by Marriott Kingston8.9Kingston
- Courtyard by Marriott Poughkeepsie8.4Poughkeepsie
- Suites on MainMargaretville6.5
- Morning Glory B&BWoodstock8.3
- Breezy Hill Inn9.8Fleischmanns
- Minnewaska LodgeGardiner8.8
- The Carriage House Loft9.5Kingston
- The StablesKingston10.0
- Residence Inn by Marriott Kingston8.6Kingston
- Slide Mountain Forest HouseOliverea8.9
- End of results -