- The Inn of Dayville7.2Dayville
- Elegant Norwich House with Billiards Room and BallroomNorwich10.0
- American Beech Hotel8.9Greenport
- Cozy Litchfield House with Fenced-In Yard and Fire PitLitchfield10.0
- Shelter Island House7.3Shelter Island Heights
- Beach Plum Resort9.0Montauk
- Americas Best Value Inn New London Mystic4.4New London
- Sole East Resort7.9Montauk
- Breezeway Boutique Hotel9.0Westerly
- Windward ShoresAmagansett8.2
- End of results -