- Oak Mar MotelOakland8.5
- Casselman InnGrantsville8.3
- Lake Pointe InnMcHenry9.4
- Comfort Inn Grantsville-Deep Creek Lake7.9Grantsville
- Finally SettledSwanton
- The Lodges at Sunset Village8.9McHenry
- SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Keyser8.8Keyser
- Mountaineer MotelMount Storm4.5
- The Garrett Inn9.5Oakland
- End of results -