- American Beech Hotel8.8Greenport
- Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach9.8Shelter Island Heights
- Shelter Island House4.0Shelter Island Heights
- Money Island Home with Deck, Kayak and Paddleboards!Branford
- Beach Plum Resort9.0Montauk
- Hilton Garden Inn Melville8.5Plainview
- Topping Rose House7.2Bridgehampton
- Villa Nostro PalazzoEast Hampton
- Sole East Resort7.6Montauk
- Windward ShoresAmagansett8.2
- End of results -