- Finally SettledSwanton
- The LoftGranville8.7
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites Culpeper by IHG8.6Culpeper
- The Loft at the BarnBolivar9.0
- Harpers Ferry Apartment with Private Pool and Hot Tub!Harpers Ferry8.5
- Courtyard Pittsburgh Settlers Ridge/Robinson Township8.5Robinson Township
- Holiday Inn Express Pittsburgh - Munhall by IHG7.9Munhall
- Super 8 by Wyndham St. Clairsville OH/Wheeling WV Area6.8Saint Clairsville
- The Lodge in Sugar HollowCrozet10.0
- Granville Inn8.9Granville
- End of results -