- TownePlace Suites by Marriott Parkersburg8.9Parkersburg
- Silver Creek Lodge9.2Snowshoe
- Hampton Inn Pittsburgh/West Mifflin8.1West Mifflin
- Fairfield Inn & Suites Bedford8.7Bedford
- Courtyard Newark Granville7.6Newark
- Residence Inn Waynesboro9.1Waynesboro
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites Fairmont by IHG8.9Fairmont
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites Cumberland - La Vale by IHG8.5La Vale
- Berlin Village Inn9.0Berlin
- Lodging on the Square8.5Berlin
- End of results -