- Yorkshire Bridge Inn9.0Bamford
- Novotel Sheffield Centre7.6Sheffield
- Chandler House9.3Castleton
- Beech croft holiday cottageCastleton9.8
- ibis budget Sheffield Arena6.8Sheffield
- The Fox House by Innkeeper's Collection8.1Hathersage
- Padley Farm9.3Bradfield
- Ibis Sheffield City8.0Sheffield
- Ramblers RestCastleton9.3
- The George9.0Hathersage
- The George InnCastleton9.1
- Ye Olde Cheshire Cheese Inn8.5Castleton
- Halifax HallSheffield8.6
- easyHotel SheffieldSheffield7.3
- Mercure Sheffield Parkway8.1Sheffield
- Ye Olde Nags Head7.8Castleton
- Old Hall cottageHope8.0
- Leopold Hotel8.5Sheffield
- Mercure Sheffield Kenwood Hall & Spa7.4Sheffield
- Best Western Sheffield City Hotel7.1Sheffield
- The Rutland Hotel7.4Sheffield
- Mercure Barnsley Tankersley Manor Hotel7.9Barnsley
- Holiday Inn Rotherham-Sheffield M1,Jct.33 by IHG8.1Rotherham
- Staindrop Hotel7.0Sheffield
- Wortley Hall Sheffield7.7Sheffield
- The Fitzwilliam Hotel7.0Rotherham
- Garrison HotelSheffield8.0
- Little John HotelHathersage8.1
- Hampton by Hilton Sheffield8.4Sheffield
- Twitchill Farm Holiday Cottage9.0Hope
- The Florentine8.4Sheffield
- Dunscar Farm Bed & BreakfastCastleton9.4
- Mullions Cottage9.2Castleton
- Carlton Park Hotel Rotherham6.2Rotherham
- Doubletree By Hilton Sheffield City8.6Sheffield
- Millstone Country Inn8.2Hathersage
- Best Western Plus The Quays Hotel Sheffield8.0Sheffield
- The Fairways7.7Rotherham
- The Welcome Inn Rotherham/SheffieldRotherham7.7
- Brecon Hotel Sheffield Rotherham6.5Rotherham
- End of results -